Posted on Thursday 5th May 2016
An analysis of primary school test results in England suggests that successful schools are not likely to improve when they become academies.
But the study, by education data firm SchoolDash, says there can be gains for disadvantaged pupils in struggling primary schools that convert.
Most secondary schools are academies, but only about one in six primary schools has changed status.
The study comes as the government wants all state schools to become academies.
Research into the achievement of academies has tended to focus on secondary schools, whose numbers have risen over more than a decade.
But if all schools are forced to become academies, the greatest impact will be among primary schools, where more than 13,000 schools will need to change.
This SchoolDash analysis compared the performance in test results of academies with local authority primaries in similar circumstances, such as levels of deprivation.
Most primary academies are "converter" academies, which tended to be high-achieving before becoming academies.
The research found "no evidence" that academy status brought improvements to these schools or that such schools were any better than their local authority counterparts.
But the smaller number of "sponsored" academies, more likely to have been previously under-achieving, made more progress when they became academies.
These improvements were "especially noticeable for disadvantaged pupils", said SchoolDash founder Timo Hannay.
"The challenge for those who support compulsory academisation is to explain why a good school should be forced to convert against its wishes if there are unlikely to be any tangible academic gains," said Dr Hannay.
"And the challenge for those who oppose it is to explain how else they would reduce the disparity between the best and the worst schools in the country, a gap that is still far too wide."
The study also shows the wide regional variations in the spread of academies.
There are some authorities where more than half of primary schools are already academies, including Bournemouth, Darlington and Middlesbrough.
Latest News
26/05/21DfE had no plan for dealing with a pandemic, says critical report by MPs
Public accounts committee also said a failure to set standards for remote learning led to ‘unequal experiences’
25/05/21Exams 2021: How will my grades be assessed this year?
Exams have been cancelled for the second year running due to the impact caused by coronavirus. The government have put schools will be in charge of grades and assessments this summer in a bid to avoid the results day chaos caused by last year's controversial algorithm.
12/05/21Face masks no longer required in classrooms
Face masks will no longer be required in secondary school classrooms in England after 17 May, the Prime Minister Boris Johnson has confirmed.
04/05/21New school uniform law will keep costs down for families with government guidance to be issued this autumn
Schools will be asked to keep branded items to a minimum when a new school uniform law comes into force later this year.
19/04/21Teaching assistants 'unsung heroes' of pandemic, study shows
UCL Institute for Education finds 88% of TAs supported vulnerable and key worker children in school